
*By Cathy Mellett, Founder and Managing Director, Net Branding*
There is a conversation happening across the marketing world right now, and every time I read another article about it I have the same thought. We have been saying this since 2008.
The conversation goes like this. As search moves into AI, the tools that build answers do not look at your website alone. They pull signals from across your whole presence. Your website, yes, but also your blog, your social media, the places people talk about you, and the trust you have built over time. The new language for this is things like topical authority and citation share, and the new worry is that brands have been treating each channel as a separate box. A silo. SEO over here, social over there, the website somewhere else, and email forgotten in a corner.
The people writing about this are right. But it is not new. At Net Branding it is the thing we have built our work around since the day we started.
What the data is now showing
Let me give you the evidence, because I am careful about that. I do not repeat numbers I cannot trace to a proper source.
The clearest recent picture comes from Tinuiti, an independent agency that tracked AI citations across nine commercial categories and seven major platforms including ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Mode, AI Overviews, Gemini, Copilot and Meta AI, over four months to January 2026. Their headline finding is the one that matters most. There is no single source that wins everywhere. There are only patterns shaped by intent, platform and category. In other words, you cannot rely on one channel to carry you.
Within that, social has become a real part of how AI builds answers. The share of AI citations coming from social media climbed steadily from October 2025 through January 2026, topping nine per cent in the first month of the year, and the variation between platforms is enormous. Reddit alone grew its citation share by at least 73 per cent across the categories Tinuiti tracked over those four months, and more than doubled in some industries. On Perplexity, around a quarter of all citations in January came from Reddit alone, while another Google product cited the same source a fraction as often. So a brand that looks well represented in one AI tool can be almost invisible in another.
Why one channel can no longer carry you
There is a deeper shift underneath those numbers, and it is the one I want business owners to understand. This is not the old search world. In traditional search the top ten results capture roughly two thirds of the clicks, so the game was to fight for those few spots. In AI search no single source dominates. Even the most cited domain on any platform rarely accounts for more than about five per cent of citations. The rest spreads across thousands of sources. That means visibility is no longer about winning one position. It is about being a credible, consistent presence across many places at once, which is exactly what a connected approach gives you and a siloed one cannot.
There is a human reason this works, not just a technical one. Psychologists have understood for decades that familiarity builds trust. The more often people encounter something in a consistent, recognisable form, the more they come to trust it, an effect documented in the research as the mere exposure effect. A connected presence, the same brand showing up coherently across search, your website, your content and your social, is simply that principle at work. Each consistent touch lowers the effort it takes someone to trust you. Scattered, contradictory pieces do the opposite.
The point I want you to take from this is not which platform is up or down this quarter. Those numbers will move. The point is the shape of it. Visibility now comes from many places at once, and they feed each other. Your website earns trust. Your content gives the AI something to cite. Your social presence extends your reach and adds the signals that say real people engage with you. Your search foundation makes all of it discoverable. Pull one piece out and the whole thing weakens.
That is the case the industry is now making with fresh data. It is also the case we made in a marketing room in Auckland in 2012, and the model we were already presenting then.

Net Branding marketing event, 14 June 2012. Posted on our Facebook page at the time. We were presenting the connected-channel model to local business audiences well before the industry had a name for it.

Be Seen, Be Heard, Be Found. The plain-language framework we paired with the tea cup to show clients what each channel was actually for.
I was presenting this at our marketing events by 2012, as the photograph above shows. In the same period I was quoted in the New Zealand Herald making exactly this argument, that social media is a powerful tool but it is best used in conjunction with other tools such as a website, and that the biggest trap for a small business is putting all of its online eggs in the social media basket. I have carried the tea cup through our presentations in the years since, refining it as the channels changed, but the core has never moved.
“Social media is a hugely effective tool and I think all businesses should have a social media presence, but it is hard work and not a one-night wonder.”
Cathy Mellett, quoted in NZ Herald Business Day, 26 October 2012.
Why the industry caught up
Here is what I find interesting. The big marketing platforms eventually arrived at the same idea and gave it a different name. They call it the flywheel. The clearest moment came in 2018, when HubSpot used its INBOUND keynote in Boston to retire the funnel and introduce the flywheel as its model for growth. That was six years after we were teaching the same circulation to clients here in Auckland. The argument they made is the same one the cup makes. A funnel is linear and stops the moment you stop pushing, whereas a connected system compounds and keeps turning. Each channel feeds the next. Brand and organic and paid work together rather than in isolation. Retention and email keep existing customers circulating back round.
If that sounds familiar, it should. It is the cup, drawn as a wheel. The thinking is the same. Build the layers, connect them, and let them feed one another so the whole thing gains momentum.
I am not claiming I invented the flywheel. The idea is older than HubSpot’s version of it, and HubSpot itself was popularising something that had existed in business thinking for years. I am saying that the principle underneath it, that your channels are not silos and that they only work properly when they are coordinated, is something we understood and built our practice around long before it had a fashionable label or a keynote stage. And now that AI search has made the cost of ignoring it so visible, it matters more than it ever has.
Where to start
If you are reading this and recognising your own scattered pieces, the honest first step is not to add another channel. It is to look at what you already have and ask whether any of it is connected. Is your content built on the keywords people actually search? Does your social point anywhere, and more than that, does any of it ever come back into your website? Is your email doing the quiet work of bringing people back, or is it sitting idle?
The question we ask clients most often is the simplest one. All that effort going into your social, where does it end up? If the answer is that it stays on the platform, you are leaving your topical authority on the table. The fix is rarely more posting. It is building the loop that brings the best of that work home, onto pages you own, where search and AI can find it and where it keeps earning long after the post has scrolled away.
We are always happy to take a look and tell you where the gaps are. That is the part we enjoy most, finding the pieces that are nearly working and joining them up so they finally pull together.
Because a cup that holds together pours a great deal better than a handful of pieces that do not.
Cathy Mellett is the Founder and Managing Director of Net Branding, one of New Zealand’s original digital agencies, established in 2008, and the author of Be Found. Be Cited. Be Trusted. She has been helping New Zealand businesses be seen, be heard and be found online since the day she started.
Sources
AI citation patterns: Tinuiti, Q1 2026 AI Citation Trends Report (developed with Profound), reported via Search Engine Land and MediaPost, February to March 2026.
LinkedIn citation growth: Profound, Answer Engine Insights, November 2025 to February 2026; corroborated by SEMrush 325,000-prompt analysis.
2012 quotation: NZ Herald Business Day, “SMEs must up the social media ante,” 26 October 2012.


